When will a crime fiction novel win the Booker?

Wolf Hall - Number 1 in the Elizabeth Seymour Mysteries Earlier this week Jim Kelly (http://www.jim-kelly.co.uk/) won the 2011 New Angle Literary Prize. Jim has been writing crime novels based in East Anglia since 2001.

Which got me thinking. Who draws the line between genre and literary fiction? And would that line ever become blurred enough to let a thriller or mystery slip through to the winning post of the Booker?

This year’s Booker shortlist includes a Western and a YA(ish) novel set in Peckham. All six books are said to be great reads, with Julian Barnes’ slim (150 page) story about male sexual rivalry (oh good) the most ‘literary’. The only vaguely thriller-esque shortlistee is Snowdrops by AD Miller.

But no out and out crime novel.

In 2010 the Australian crime writer Peter Temple won the prestigious Miles Franklin award – Australia’s top literary prize. Which got a the literati in this country a bit twitchy. Well written genre fiction? Come on.

In the past there have been novels on the shortlist or longlist that might have ticked the ‘high quality’ crime/thriller fiction box. In 2002 Sarah Waters was nominated for Fingersmith – a Victorian psychological crime novel in the Wilkie Collins mould. She didn’t go on to win the Booker, but she did nab the CWA’s Historical Crime Fiction Dagger.

In 2008 Tom Rob Smith’s Moscow thriller Child 44 was longlisted.

Close, but I don’t see anyone flashing cigars. Equally, on the other side of the Atlantic, George Pelicanos and Dennis Lehane are flying the flag for the riveting plot/fine prose combo, but neither have won the Pulitzer.

If crime is good enough for the likes of Kate Atkinson (Jackson Brodie series), Ian McEwan (Saturday), John Banville (writing as Benjamin Black) and William Boyd (Ordinary Thunderstorms) then maybe the literary establishment needs to take the genre a tad more seriously.

Or we just have to wait for Hilary Mantel to invent a new female sleuth (Murder at Wolf Hall, anyone?)


About Eva Hudson
Eva Hudson is an author who specialises in writing crime thrillers featuring strong female leads. Eva was born and raised in south London and now splits her time between the Sussex countryside and central London. She’s been a government officer, singer, dotcom entrepreneur, portrait artist, web designer and project manager. In 2011 she won the inaugural Lucy Cavendish fiction prize for her first novel, political thriller, The Loyal Servant.

2 Responses to When will a crime fiction novel win the Booker?

  1. Yep! Couldn’t agree more :) Thanks for great read.

  2. Pingback: Science and the conspiracy: a review of “Ordinary Thunderstorms” | cartesian product

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s